Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Trial begins for Melvin Scherrer
Drug Ring

Trial begins for Melvin Scherrer

This trial for drug distribution, his murder charges still pending

  • Updated
  • 0
Trial begins against Melvin Scherrer web

Melvin Scherrer of rural Bonne Terre is on trial this week on his federal drug charges, accused of supplying ice (crystal meth) to the area.

Scherrer is charged in federal court with conspiracy to distribute/possess with intent to distribute more than 500 grams of a meth mixture; felon in possession of a firearm; and possession of a firearm in furtherance of drug trafficking. 

The charges stemmed from a drug investigation that began in late 2010 and led to a 25-person indictment in September of 2013 and also involved Scherrer and another man, Brent Bouren, being charged with murder in connection with the death of Samuel Francis, a tattoo artist.

Several of the 25 charged are members of the Saddle Tramps Motorcycle Club. The case was a joint operation of the FBI, DEA, ATF, Missouri State Highway Patrol, St. Charles and Jefferson County sheriff’s offices, St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department and multiple local law enforcement agencies including the St. Francois County Sheriff’s Department. 

During the first day of trial jurors heard opening statements from both U.S. Assistant District Attorney Jeannette Graviss and Scherrer's attorney, John Stobbs. 

Graviss told jurors that Scherrer has distributed ice to numerous individuals in Southeast Missouri for many years. Those individuals sold the drugs to other people. 

On Monday, the first day of trial, Graviss called three witnesses — a Missouri State Highway Patrol criminal investigator who testified briefly, showing photographs taken of evidence seized from Scherrer in January of 2013; an FBI agent who provided more details of the investigation, search warrants and suspects; and Amanda Francis who lived with Scherrer for "a few weeks at a time" while separated from her husband, Sam Francis. 

The woman testified she was in a romantic relationship with Scherrer and he provided her with lines of meth. She said Scherrer also did drugs. She said she did ice while she was partying but has never been addicted to it. 

She said she saw Scherrer distribute meth to individuals including three transactions to Bouren. 

Bouren, publisher and editor of Full Throttle Midwest Magazine, has pleaded guilty to his federal charges of conspiracy to distribute cocaine and conspiracy to distribute meth. A sentencing date has not been set. Like Scherrer, his murder charges in St. Francois County are still pending with no trial date set.

She said she also saw Mark Abney and Otto Plopper, two others facing charges in connection with the investigation, get meth. Abney has pleaded guilty to conspiracy to distribute a controlled substance and is scheduled to be sentenced later this month.

When asked about Arvil Matthews, she initially said she had not seen a transaction with him. When reminded of what she had previously told investigators, she said she couldn't specifically remember an exchange but indicated she had been at his house. 

Matthews, the Saddle Tramps Motorcycle Club president, was sentenced to 96 months in prison followed by six years of supervised release for conspiracy to distribute meth. He has filed an appeal to the sentence. 

Graviss asked the woman if she knew anyone in the courtroom audience and also asked, "are you afraid of testifying today?"

"I'm not exactly comfortable with it," she responded.

When asked if she saw Howard "Bud" Pyatt purchase meth, she initially said no but then said she saw Pyatt hand Scherrer a wad of cash. Pyatt has been sentenced to 30 months in federal prison for conspiracy to distribute meth in the indictment.

She said Scherrer told her the meth was from "the Mexicans" and he needed $70,000 to $75,000 to get a supply of meth. 

The FBI agent testified that the investigation began when they started looking into a man who is not charged in the indictment. It was determined that this man manufactured his own meth and also bought ice from Matthews. The investigation of Matthews led to an investigation of Scherrer as Matthews' source of the drug. 

The investigation which included search warrants and wire tapping of individuals' phones went on for two years trying to determine how the Mexican meth was getting into the area.

During one of several search warrants served, the FBI seized Scherrer's DVR obtaining a week's worth of surveillance footage from Scherrer's own video cameras installed throughout his Cedar Lake property. While the surveillance footage didn't have audio, Graviss showed jurors selected clips of footage from several different angles showing Scherrer handling a gun which, by law, he is not allowed to do because he is a convicted felon.

It also shows Jorge Lopez arriving at the home. According to the prosecution, Lopez, an owner of a car lot in Texas, was supplying Scherrer with meth or ice from Mexico. At least one stolen Chevrolet Camaro was given to Lopez by Scherrer, the investigators said.

Lopez, of Corinth, Texas, has been sentenced to 10 years in prison followed by five years of supervised release for conspiracy to distribute meth for his part in the indictment. The FBI agent indicated Lopez had been investigated in 2010 about cocaine coming across Mexico. 

Footage on another day showed Bouren and Matthews engaging in drug activity at Scherrer's kitchen table. 

The trial will resume at 9 a.m. Tuesday at the federal courthouse in St. Louis. The trial is expected to wrap up by Friday.


Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News